Tunisia Secretly Tested Censorship Software for Western Companies

Moez Chakchouk

Moez Chakchouk (ATI) describes his mission. By Mohamed Alâa Guedich (used with permission)

The new chairman and CEO of the Tunisian Internet Agency (ATI), Moez Chakchouk, told participants at the Arab Bloggers Meeting today that western companies offered significant discounts on use of censorship software to the Tunisian government in exchange for testing and bug-tracking. He said confidentiality contracts preclude him from naming the companies, but said the Internet Agency has extracted itself from these partnerships and thus can no longer afford to censor, even if they wished to (he says they don’t anymore).

Thanks to the change in leadership of the government agency previously charged with censorship and surveillance, Chakchouk is now encouraging bloggers and activists to push for better regulation and constitutional protections for online free speech.

From Jillian C. York’s liveblog of Day One:

“Even if we wanted to censor, we’d have to consider the court decisions – there was a court decision in an appeals court without any prior references. We need to change ATI, make it an IXP, and provide more transparency.” — Moez Chakchouk, President and CEO, ATI

Moez Chakchouk is the president of the Tunisian Internet Agency (ATI). I recently interviewed him for a forthcoming piece, and his talk today was within the same framework: how to build up the ATI as an Internet Exchange Point (IXP) whilst ensuring that the ATI is neutral and free of censorship. He offered considerable detail on the goals and accomplishments of the ATI thus far (which I’ll spare you here, as it’s included in my upcoming piece – well, and because I couldn’t see the slides well enough from my position in the back row!)

Moez also, as Nasser Weddady put it, “[blew] a huge hole in tech companies’ claim that their equipment sale to repressive regimes [are] in good faith.” Tunisia long used SmartFilter (owned by McAfee/Intel) to censor the Internet and continues to do so (though at a very different level: see my post here). Slim Amamou (@slim404) commented afterward on the sale of surveillance and censorship equipment by American and European companies to foreign regimes, particularly Tunisia.

A little background: The ATI was long an enemy of Tunisians; charged with censorship and surveillance under Ben Ali, it was a feared agency, its practices referred to widely as “Ammar 404,” in honor of the 404 error users received when trying to access a blocked site. Post-revolution, the options were to shut down Ammar 404 and the ATI, or leave the ATI open as a semi-government agency, charged with being Tunisia’s IXP. Moez and others have faced several attempts to shut down the Internet, but continue their fight for an open and neutral Internet.

The Spanish 15M Movement and the Arab Inspiration

Spanish-Syrian blogger Leila Nachawati. By Nasnas (CC BY-NC-ND 2.0)

Here are slides from a presentation by Spanish-Syrian blogger Leila Nachawati on Day One about how the Arab uprisings inspired and informed the people’s movement in Spain and elsewhere in Europe.

Here’s one comment from the audience:

@donatelladr: “we are sorry:we dont have a leader so u cant defeat us” great quote from Spanigh revolution by @leila_na #AB11 so true!

Crash Course on Mobile Security

Arturo and Jake scare everybody.

Arturo and Jake scare everybody. Photo by Mohamed Alâa Guedich (used with permission)

Jacob Appelbaum and Arturo Buzzolan from Tor offered advice on mobile security on Day One of the Arab Bloggers Meeting with a presentation that shows just how easy it is for governments to track and intercept mobile and satellite phone conversations. “Think of your phone as a tracking device that also makes calls,” says Appelbaum.

One comment on Twitter:

@__Hisham: If I learned one thing from today’s Tor team presentation it’s this: “Don’t trust your phone… at all!”

This is their slideshow:

Blogs and Media: #AB11

We’ve got a meeting room full of bloggers. If you’ve written something to help document the meeting, please share the link so we can add to the list. This post will be updated!

Blog posts

And after…

Day Four

Day Three

Day Two

Day One

Media

And after…

Day Four

Day Three

Day Two

Day One

Photos From #AB11

We’ll be updating this post with links to photos from the Arab Bloggers Summit. If you upload photos to Flickr please use the hashtag #AB11 or share link in comments.

The 3rd Arab Bloggers Meeting

The seats reserved for Palestinian bloggers who were not given visas to attend Arab Bloggers Meeting. Photo by Ibtihel Zaatouri (CC-BY-2.0)

"Revolution Shall be Twitterised" panel at 3rd Arab Bloggers Mtg #AB11

“Revolution Shall be Twitterised” panel, featuring Arab tweeps who collectively have more than 124,000 followers. By Georgia Popplewell (CC-BY-NC-SA 2.0)

Internet Securiy
Jacob Appelbaum and Arturo Buzzolan offer advice on mobile security: “Think of your phone as a tracking device that also makes calls.” By Nasnas (CC BY-NC-ND 2.0)

Rebecca MacKinnon (@RmacK) of @globalvoices keynotes @ 3rd Arab Bloggers Summit #AB11

A slide during Rebecca MacKinnon’s talk about the need to hold both governments and technology companies accountable for internet freedom (Read more on “Dog Poop Girl” and South Korean online vigilantism). By Georgia Popplewell (CC-BY-NC-SA 2.0)